“Ma’am, I forgot my book at home.”
“Ma’am, I have lost my book.”
“Ma’am, I have lent my book to my friend.”
“Ma’am, I have to buy the book yet.”
These were the excuses I used to hear every day from some of
my 11th standard students.
The story dates back to my days as an Assistant Professor
of English in a college. I had been assigned classes for 11th standard,
FYBA, SYBA, and TYBA. Though I had a good connection with students and
genuinely enjoyed teaching them, my 11th standard class not only gave me the
experience of a lifetime but also compelled me to think deeply about an
important question:
Skill or Study — What Do Students Need More Today?
A Classroom That Tested My Patience
It was a class of around 95 students—noisy, unruly, and
undisciplined. In the beginning, they gave me a tough time. They didn’t
listen, didn’t settle in class, laughed without reason, and constantly
disrupted the lecture.
After a few days of consistent effort, they finally began to
settle down. I started teaching according to the syllabus with complete
dedication.
Within a couple of days, however, I observed that some
students did not have their textbooks. When I questioned them, they gave the
usual excuses I mentioned earlier.
But one particular excuse still makes me wonder.
“Ma’am, my book is in the bag!”
“Then why don’t you take it out?” I asked in surprise.
“Ma’am, I don’t feel like it!” he replied lazily.
“Take out your book and open page number 18,” I instructed
strictly.
He complied, though with clear disgust on his face.
I warned the entire class to bring their books to college
every day and concentrate on what was being taught. Some brought their books
the next day, some didn’t, and some simply bunked the class.
“Ma’am, You Don’t Know How Much Stress We Have”
Another day, while explaining the meaning of a poem with
great intensity and devotion, I noticed one of the students sleeping with his
head on the desk.
I walked up to him.
“Why are you sleeping?” I asked.
“Ma’am, I couldn’t sleep at night,” he replied drowsily.
“Why couldn’t you sleep?” I asked, irritated.
“Ma’am, you don’t know how much stress we have in life!”
I didn’t know how to respond.
I quietly returned to my place and continued the lecture.
Students Without Interest in Studies
Within a few months, I realized something troubling. Many of
these students had no real interest in studying or even coming to college.
It felt as though they had been pushed out of their homes
and into an education system they had no connection with.
Still, like a responsible teacher, I tried to convince them
that education was important and that they should sincerely attend college and
learn with interest and integrity.
Most of them came from average families and were
academically below average.
“See, your parents are sending you to college while they
themselves are struggling financially,” I tried to explain.
They simply stared at me blankly, as if this argument meant
nothing to them.
Sometimes a few of them smiled while I taught, lost in their
own thoughts. Others looked confused.
But they were innocent, I am sure.
Small Efforts, Small Victories
Whenever I gave exercises to solve, I would walk around the
class and sit beside them, explaining patiently how to solve them.
They struggled.
They tried.
They succeeded—sometimes a little, sometimes a little more.
Then they would eagerly ask me to check their notebooks.
I checked them carefully, corrected their mistakes, and
gently guided them. I made sure that encouragement and appreciation were
always greater than criticism.
The Honest Answer
One day I finally asked the question that had been troubling
me for months.
“Why do you come to college if you have no interest in
studies?”
They replied honestly:
“Because our parents want us to.”
I paused for a moment and asked another question.
“Why don’t you learn some skill instead, start earning, and
support your family?”
They didn’t respond.
Perhaps the idea itself was too unfamiliar for them to
understand.
Skill vs Study: The Questions We Must Ask
This experience left me with several important questions
about today’s education system:
- Should
students who have no interest in academics be forced to attend school or
college?
- Can
our education system include practical skills along with studies so
that students can express their talents and earn a livelihood?
- Is
teaching poetry more important to students who struggle to appreciate it,
or should we help them develop skills they are naturally good at?
- Should
education be spontaneous and interest-driven, or should it remain a
compulsion?
- Is a
degree or certificate more important than learning a practical
skill that can make someone financially independent?
These questions lie at the heart of the skill vs study debate in modern education.
Rethinking Education: Helping Students Discover Their
Potential
Years have passed since that classroom of 95 restless
students, yet their faces remain vivid in my memory.
They were not incapable.
They were not unintelligent.
They were simply part of a system that often measures ability through textbooks
alone.
The boy who said, “My book is in the bag,” may not have
lacked ability—perhaps he lacked motivation and connection with what he was
learning.
The student who spoke of “stress” may not have been making
excuses—perhaps he was struggling silently with pressures we could not see.
Education should not feel like a burden that students carry
unwillingly every morning. Instead, it should be a pathway that helps them
discover their strengths and build a meaningful future.
A degree can decorate a wall.
A skill can build a livelihood.
But an education system that balances knowledge,
practical skills, curiosity, and freedom of choice can build confident and
capable human beings.
Perhaps that is what today’s students truly need—not merely
study or skill alone, but an education that respects both.

So apt! I got multiple thoughts while reading this beautiful blog and would share the most relevant two:
ReplyDelete1. Not all teachers or professors take such genuine efforts to connect beneath the surface and help kids to think rationally and then act this
2. Yes the push from parents without knowing what their kids really want to do is a real "stress". Following what the child seeks is more important than what the societal norms are. Also, once the connection is real, they too are receptive to certain necessary doings positively, like getting across the basic education levels.
Wonderful blog Anjali - keep writing, your blogs are a healthy food of thought for mind.
Thank you so much for such beautiful words of appreciation and encouragement! Always grateful!
DeleteI love this blog. I really appreciate the focus on student-centered learning.
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot for reading and appreciating!
DeleteVery well written article. It shows our education system really needs an upgrade to include both knowledge and skills for better future of students.
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot!
DeleteAs a teacher I could relate to this! Wonderful❤
ReplyDeleteThank you so much!
DeleteBeautifully written!!
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot!
DeleteAwesome!❤❤
ReplyDeleteThank you so much!
DeleteRandomly came across this and once I started reading it I just couldn't stop until I read the whole thing! Amazing!
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot!
DeleteBeautifully expressed the feeling of being a teacher! It can be annoying sometimes when the students are not paying attention yet there is a feeling that afterall they are students and we should give them a break sometimes and let them have fun too! This is my personal experience as a teacher who has been teaching as a professor in a college and the students seem to really like me since I started applying this way of teaching!
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot for reading and appreciating!
Deletewell written!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much!
DeleteI really eager to read your articles, dear
ReplyDeleteKeep it up
Thank you so much! Always grateful!
DeleteBeautifully written. Keep writing such beautiful experiences💐
ReplyDeleteThank you so much! Always grateful!
Delete